Litter Genie vs. Litter Genie Plus vs. Litter Genie XL – Which One To Choose?

"I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post."

Litter Genie vs Plus vs XL

Below is our comparison of Litter Genie vs Litter Genie Plus, which are two decent cat litter systems.

Cats are such amiable creatures that many people keep them as their pets. Apart from pleasurable moments with these companions, cat owners must have experienced difficult times brought on by their cat litter at least once.

If you find yourself in the same boat, continue scrolling down, and you will surely find an optimum solution.

About the Litter Genie Brand

The Litter Genie brand was founded in 2012 and has made significant changes to litter odor control ever since. The design is by no means complex but surprisingly offers a one-size-fits-all solution that ensures a matchless experience.

Throughout many years of operation, the brand has made lives easier for cat keepers. With this product, disposing of your pet litter is no longer a difficult and time-consuming task. You can shop for Litter Genie in a variety of shops, both online and offline.

Litter Genie vs. Litter Genie Plus vs. Litter Genie XL

1. Litter Genie



With Litter Genie, dealing with your cat litter has now become as easy as A B C. The product is ideal for locking germs and bacteria from the waste away, thus repelling unpleasant smells.

To achieve that, the manufacturers put a seven-layer cartridge in the base pail, and it can last up to two months for every cat and employs the odor barrier technology.

What is more, the pail can hold the cat litter for a space of 14 days (for a cat) so you can save a lot of time previously used to carry out trash trips.

Made up of multiple litter boxes, Little Genie is an ideal choice for small places and your homes. For the sake of quick and trouble-free cleanup, the pail should be placed within easy reach of the box.

Coming to an affordable price per product, Litter Genie is absolutely a necessity rather than a luxury for any cat owner. On top of that, you need not fret over its quality, which is approved by Jackson Galaxy-a cat behaviorist with 20 years of expertise.

Of course, Litter Genie is not flawless, much of which results from its rather pricey cartridges. However, it is still a decent cat litter disposal system considering its benefits.

  • Pocket-friendly
  • Easy to use
  • Put your cat litter in control
  • Expensive cartridges

2. Litter Genie Plus



The Little Genie is already good, but when you want some more decent features, Little Genie Plus comes in. Interestingly, the company still charges you the same.

First and foremost, this model is available in different option colors when compared to the original one: navy, espresso, and black.

Similar to Litter Genie, the question as to how to dispose of cat litter has become easier than ever before. Besides, Litter Genie Plus refill is 30% more long-lasting than that of the original version, while still offering standard quality.

What is more, the product gives you absolute control over unwanted odor thanks to the addition of the built-in antimicrobial protection.

Flaunting such amazing features, the Litter Genie Plus can be expensive when including the cost of the bags. However, it is a foregone conclusion that the model is among one of the best waste systems for cats currently available.

  • Include all the features of Litter Genie
  • Affordable
  • Provide more choices of colors
  • Stronger refill cartridge
  • Costly refill bags

3. Litter Genie XL Pail Reviews



Here comes Litter Genie XL’s review, which is often sought after as an alternative to the aforementioned products.

Actually, the structure and usage of Litter Genie vs Litter Genie XL or Litter Genie Plus vs XL are almost the same. The only difference is that the XL model is taller and wider than both the original and Plus versions. For this reason, it is ideal for homes with multiple cats.

Integrated into the XL pail is a noticeable seven-layer refill cartridge that lasts up to 8 weeks with one cat. The XL pail holds up to 21 days of cat litter (for one cat) which is 50% more than that standard or Litter Genie Plus.

This system has the same features as the Litter Genie, thus it is quite intuitive right from the first time of use.

What is more, its ability to lock away odor and the simplified cleaning process puts both the cats and their owners at ease.

However, it is available in silver only and comes at higher than the above models.

  • Easy to use
  • Prevent disgusting smells from escaping
  • Simplified cleanup work
  • More pricey than other versions
  • Only one choice of color is available


On finishing reading our comprehensive Litter Genie reviews, you may, like everyone else, reach the conclusion that the Litter Genie Plus stands customers in better stead than the other model. With this product, dealing with your pet waste is no longer a daunting task, considering its perfect features.

Litter Genie Hacks

smelly cat litter box
Image Credit: catinsyrup, Shutterstock

We have mentioned above that both models are easy to refill, and now we will show you Litter Genie hacks that facilitate your cleanup. To carry them out, you will need 1 Litter Genie, 1 refill, ordinary plastic grocery bags, and either a rubber band or reusable bag clip.

Litter Genie Hacks:
  • Step 1: Apply the clip to the Litter Genie bag. The instruction indicates that you should knot the bag at the side of the unused part, but we suggest attaching its bottom with a clip. For the sake of a secure seal, you should twist the bag twice.
  • Step 2: Put a plastic grocery bag into the Litter Genie pail. Line the pail of the system with one or more normal plastic bags. The number of bags you use is directly proportional to the convenience of disposal. It does not matter whether the bags overlap the pail edges when you close the Litter Genie lid.
  • Step 3: Put Litter Genie bag end in the shopping bags. Place the product bag inside the grocery bag. When the bag is full, you just need to remove the clip, dump the litter into the grocery bag, and dispose of it. Change a new clip and put the litter bag end inside the grocery bag. Close the Litter Genie and repeat this process. Seeing funky blue bags means they should be cut off, and a new section should be used.

If you stick to our advice, your Litter Genie can last for approximately one year, thus reducing the amount of money you spend on the product.


Is the Litter Genie Plus worth it?

Litter Genie Plus is fitted up with more highlights, namely more aesthetic looks, and stronger refills. It offers an optimum solution to your problems, helping you scoop the cat litter easily and keep your house odor-free.

For this reason, we can assure you that Litter Genie Plus is good value for money and if you do not like it, you are certainly going against the trend.

Can a Diaper Genie be used for kitty litter?

If you have both babies and cats, what is the reason for not trying out Diaper Genie? Being a baby diaper disposal system, it can also handle cats-related tasks as well.

You can use them to get rid of poop from a kitty litter box or doggy poop bags. Similar to the Litter Genie, the Diaper Genie is ideal for preventing smells from escaping.

The product is so high quality that when you search “Diaper Genie review”, you will see dozens of compliments on it. For this reason, it is entirely feasible to use a Diaper Genie in place of a Litter Genie for your kitty.

cat outside of the liter box
Image Credit: Jennifer McCallum, Shutterstock

How do you use Litter Genie Plus?

Simple Litter Genei Plus Instructions:
  • One: On the top half is a cartridge that has one bag open at both ends. After identifying that, you push it past a spring-loaded slider and then into the base to put the system into operation.
  • Two: Next, use the scoop to sift through your pet’s litter and dump the clumps into the top of the pail. When you pull out the handle, your scoop will fall to the bottom of the bag.
  • Three: That the handle retracts makes a seal in the bag, which serves as a shield to protect your house from the unwanted smell.
  • Four: Last, of all, you need to fill up the bag in the pail. Bear in mind that the top half of the Genie must be folded so as to reveal the full bag at the bottom.
  • Five: The pail is fitted up with a safety razor in the middle, making it easy to cut the bag at the top. At this point, you can tie the bag and get rid of it in no time.
How to Use the Litter Genie Plus:
  • Step One: Scoop your pet waste
  • Step Two: Open the lid and dump what you scooped before
  • Step Three: Close the lid and pull the handle so that unpleasant smells can be locked away.

How long does a Litter Genie refill last?

As a rule, a Litter Genie refill has a lifetime of 8 weeks for each cat. How long it lasts surely depends upon the number of cats you have. You can expect each bag cartridge to last up to two months for one cat, and one month for two cats

What’s different between Litter Genie Plus refill vs. standard refill?

The Litter Genie Plus refill is larger and taller than the standard refill, which belongs to the original version. The Plus model also comes with more refills, which are both larger and taller than the other units.

Do all models use the same standard refills?

Yes, all of their refill cartridges are designed to fit all the pails, standard, plus, and XL, taking the hassle out of buying refills.

cat licking paws
Image Credit: AntonMaltsev, Shutterstock


Above is our definitive review of Litter Genie vs Litter Genie Plus, and hopefully, it provides you with information as to the pros and cons of these systems, hacks, etc. If you have any queries, feel free to leave a comment below so that we can help figure them out.

In case the product does not work properly, you should:

  • Not fix it yourself
  • Bring it to the retailer you bought it to have it repaired
  • If you are looking for other product reviews like our Litter Genie vs Litter Genie Plus, visit us for more!

2 thoughts on “Litter Genie vs. Litter Genie Plus vs. Litter Genie XL – Which One To Choose?”

  1. You didn’t mention much about refills – except that they were expensive. Do all models use the same standard refills?

    • Hi CandC,

      Yes, all of their refill cartridges are designed to fit all the pails, standard, plus, and XL, taking the hassle out of buying refills.

Comments are closed.

Did you know: an average of 8 cat foods are recalled every year?

Get FREE Cat Food Recall Alerts by email whenever there's a recall.